Site Behavior Lab
Site

www.theguardian.com

Baseline visit
Requested address
https://www.theguardian.com/
Report ID
20260817-2134674e3ea29e8ebcf1d4735a978d54
Evidence SHA-256
d2b66576c9c412f4644f318f43f0fa83636ca0b0dded6963bdd57b2f38b6a991
Scanner
playwright-chromium

Public corrections ledger · SBL-CORR-2026-005

This report has a reviewed clarification

SBL-CORR-2026-002: The policy entity matcher did not recognize Amazon and Oracle under their catalog names. An unmentioned-entity result for Amazon Ads or Oracle Advertising is not reliable evidence that the policy omitted the company. Original policy text was not retained, so individual mention results cannot be reconstructed. Consult all clarification events for this report.

SBL-CORR-2026-005: In these reports the privacy-policy cross-check read a privacy hub, a page that links to the site's policy without containing it, as the policy itself. Company names were matched only against that page, so the card listing tracking companies the policy does not appear to name is not evidence that the policy omits them, and the policy may name them. Requests and other observations are unaffected. Consult all clarification events for this report.

Read the public review record

theguardian.com recorded 561 fewer third-party requests in the visit configured for Brave-list blocking.

Where this page's requests went

Both visits. One mark is one request row in the retained log.

No blocking

www.theguardian.com itself29 requestsrequests that stayed on the site
Catalogued services253 requests22 names: PubMatic 48, Google 35, Magnite 31, Amazon Ads 24, The Trade Desk 19, and 17 more
Hosts the catalog does not name403 requests90 hosts; the catalog cannot say who operates them

Brave-list blocking

www.theguardian.com itself14 requestsrequests that stayed on the site
Catalogued services0 requestsno retained request matched the service catalog
Hosts the catalog does not name95 requests4 hosts; the catalog cannot say who operates them
Not measuredabsence here is not evidence of absence
  • Other pages on this site
  • Signed-in visitors, other browsers and other regions
  • Anything that loads only after interaction or consent
  • Services the catalog does not name
  • Checks with incomplete evidence
  • one request on record, same site
  • one request on record, cross-site
  • not measured

The visit with no blocking made 685 requests; the visit configured to apply Brave's ad-block engine and default Shields filter lists (a simulation in this scanner's browser, not a live Brave-browser visit) recorded 561 fewer third-party requests. The blocker directly stopped 23 requests; the remaining difference may include follow-on requests that never started once their sources were blocked, plus run-to-run variance. SBL-CORR-2026-005: In these reports the privacy-policy cross-check read a privacy hub, a page that links to the site's policy without containing it, as the policy itself. Company names were matched only against that page, so the card listing tracking companies the policy does not appear to name is not evidence that the policy omits them, and the policy may name them. Requests and other observations are unaffected. Consult all clarification events for this report.

22tracking-service entities
656cross-site requests
158third-party cookie records

Review-worthy

Bottom line: this visit has review-worthy signals

The scan observed signals a non-expert should not have to decode from raw request tables. Some detector evidence was incomplete; each affected detector card states its own retained or unavailable scope, while completed request, cookie, and storage measurements keep their recorded exactness.

Where severity is ranked, the cohort is a curated set of popular, mostly commercial sites, not a random sample of the web. Details

The cards below translate the evidence into plain language. Where a measured distribution exists, severity ranks this visit against percentiles from this report's cohort, with each percentile card naming its metric-specific measured-site denominator; otherwise it uses fixed reference thresholds. That cohort is drawn from a curated set of popular, mostly commercial sites, not a random sample of the web. The request log, domain table, and methodology remain below for verification.

685 requests observed in one controlled visit.

What was checked

Page
Requested https://www.theguardian.com/; both visits landed on https://www.theguardian.com/us
When
Aug 17, 2026, 6:07 AM UTC
Setup
Both visits used headless Chromium in a desktop window of 1440 × 980, with en-US language and UTC time zone. Both ran from a GitHub Actions Ubuntu runner; the network region was not recorded. Neither sent the Global Privacy Control (GPC) signal.
Visits
Two visits configured to differ in Brave-list blocking: No blocking and Brave-list blocking.
Interactions
No typing was recorded in either visit. No scrolling, clicking or consent interaction.
Outcome
Both visits completed, but some evidence in the No blocking visit was cut short.

What these visits could not see

  • Other pages on this site. Only the requested page's activity was recorded. The privacy policy was opened only to read its text, and none of its activity was recorded.
  • Signed-in visitors, other browsers and other regions. Both visits were automated, from a fixed en-US / UTC profile. Sites can behave differently for real users, browsers, regions, accounts, or network locations.
  • Anything that loads only after interaction or consent. Trackers that load that late are not observed, so counts are a lower bound.
  • Services the catalog does not name. Service labels use a US-biased hand-curated catalog, so regional services may be under-labeled.
  • Checks with incomplete evidence. In the No blocking visit only: the privacy policy check, fingerprinting, session-recording signals, the typing test, CNAME cloaking, advertising pixels and the consent banner. Each linked card states what was retained.

Worth checking

341 requests matched Brave Shields filter lists

341 requests matched the default filter lists of Brave Shields, the ad and tracker blocker built into the Brave browser, while loading normally.

Blocking can also prevent follow-on requests, so this number is neither a measured block count nor what a Brave visit would block. Details

Computed with Brave's own ad-block engine and default filter lists in classification mode: matched requests were not blocked by the scanner and remain in this report's observed request counts. This is Site Behavior Lab's list-based simulation, which applies every list to the site's own requests too. Brave's default Standard setting skips most of these lists for such requests, so its results can differ.

The hand-curated service catalog separately matched 253 request rows in this visit.Show matched requests

Not flagged

Lower values observed across comparable metrics in the Brave-list blocking attempt

The blocking visit ran with the scanner configured to apply Brave's ad-block engine and default Shields filter lists. It was a simulation in this scanner's browser, not a live Brave-browser visit, and application was not verified. Compared with the unblocked visit, it showed 561 fewer third-party requests, 158 fewer third-party cookies and 253 fewer tracking-related service requests.

Treat this as an observed difference, not a measured blocking rate. Details

Services only seen in the unblocked visit: PubMatic, Google and Magnite, plus 19 others. The blocking visit's engine directly blocked 23 requests; the remaining difference may include follow-on requests that never started once their sources were blocked. A single paired comparison can also reflect run-to-run variance (ad rotation, caching, experiments).

Signed per-metric differences between the two visits; nothing is summed across metrics.Show matched requests

Context

Tracking companies the privacy policy does not appear to name

PubMatic, The Trade Desk and Index Exchange, plus 6 others were sent requests during this visit. However, the policy text matched none of the names this scan knows those companies by. This read checked at most 12 unnamed companies, so 8 more observed tracking companies were not checked: Comscore, LiveRamp and Lotame, plus 5 others.

Policies often disclose vendor categories rather than company names, so an unnamed vendor is a transparency gap worth reviewing, not automatically a violation. Details

Named in the policy: Google and LinkedIn.

Policy at https://www.theguardian.com/…/privacy; 0 checkable statements matched; 2 of 11 checked tracking companies named in the policy. Policy mentions of Magnite, Amazon Ads and Equativ are unknown because the historical alias matcher was incomplete. This read checked at most 12 unnamed companies, so 8 more observed tracking companies were not checked: Comscore, LiveRamp and Lotame, plus 5 others.

Look closer

Show catalog-matched requests

Opens the request log at its catalog-matched rows, which include the requests to the companies this card names.

Review-worthy

Catalogued service domains recorded responses during this visit

PubMatic, Google and Magnite, plus 19 others appeared in the request log.

A catalog match identifies a maintainer-reviewed service/domain mapping; it does not establish why an individual request occurred, what it carried, or whether profiling happened. Details

Functional catalog labels include advertising / supply-side platform, advertising and advertising / demand-side platform. This scan could not identify 88 of the 122 third-party hosts recorded here, so it cannot say who operates them. That is a limit of identity coverage, not evidence about the site.

656 cross-site requests across 122 third-party hosts.At or above the 90th-percentile mark for third-party domains across the 86 sites measured for this metric. High distinct tracking-service entities count (at or above the 12 reference threshold).Show third-party requests

Context

Requests were dispatched to catalogued major-platform domains

This visit dispatched requests to catalogued domains for Google and LinkedIn.

The domain matches identify services, not the requests' purpose, payload, or whether any profile linking occurred.

39 requests to these platforms.Show catalog-matched requests

Not flagged

No Google Analytics observed

This visit did not contact Google Analytics.

This does not prove the site never uses Google Analytics; it means this visit recorded no request to it. Details

Google Analytics was not observed in this visit.

No google-analytics.com, analytics.google.com or googletagmanager.com requests.Show catalog-matched requests

Review-worthy

Third-party cookies were present

158 third-party cookies showed up during the visit.

This report does not retain cookie values or partition keys, so it does not establish whether a cookie was a persistent identifier or could recognize a visitor across sites. Details

The scanner observed cookie metadata whose domain crossed the scanned site's registrable-domain boundary.

176 cookies total in this report.At or above the 90th-percentile mark for third-party cookies across the 86 sites measured for this metric.

Context

Incomplete evidence: No fingerprint-like API calls observed in retained evidence before collection stopped

The retained evidence holds no calls to the instrumented high-entropy browser APIs.

Evidence collection was cut short, so this covers only what was recorded before the cutoff. Details

This is an observation layer, not proof that fingerprinting is impossible.

Retained incomplete evidence includes 0 API event records; no exact API-family total is available.

Domain evidence

124 recorded domains
The busiest recorded domains of the No blocking visit, with role, request count, request start times and catalog match.
DomainRequestsWhen, 0 to 10.6 sCatalog matchRoleResource types
assets.guim.co.uk69No catalog matchthird-partyother, font, script, stylesheet, document
*.pubmatic.com41PubMatic: advertising / supply-side platformservicefetch, xhr, script, image, document
*.*.doubleclick.net30Google: advertisingservicescript, document, image, other, fetch
*.guim.co.uk30No catalog matchthird-partyimage
*.gumgum.com27No catalog matchthird-partydocument, image
*.theguardian.com25No catalog matchfirst-partyfetch, script, xhr, document, stylesheet
*.amazon-adsystem.com22Amazon Ads: advertisingservicescript, xhr, document, image
*.adsrvr.org19The Trade Desk: advertising / demand-side platformservicefetch, image, document
*.the-ozone-project.com18No catalog matchthird-partyfetch, document, xhr, image
*.casalemedia.com17Index Exchange: advertising / exchangeservicefetch, document, image
*.rubiconproject.com16Magnite: advertising / supply-side platformservicefetch, document, script, xhr, image
*.openx.net15OpenX: advertising / exchangeservicefetch, document, image
pixel.rubiconproject.com15Magnite: advertising / supply-side platformserviceimage
*.analytics.yahoo.com15No catalog matchthird-partyscript, xhr, document, image
pixel.adsafeprotected.com13No catalog matchthird-partyxhr, image
*.presage.io13No catalog matchthird-partydocument, image
*.3lift.com12TripleLift: advertising / supply-side platformservicefetch, document, image
*.bidswitch.net12No catalog matchthird-partyimage, document
api.permutive.com11No catalog matchthird-partyxhr, image
*.*.bidr.io11No catalog matchthird-partyimage, document
creativecdn.com8No catalog matchthird-partyimage, document
ads.pubmatic.com7PubMatic: advertising / supply-side platformservicescript, document, image
*.smartadserver.com7Equativ: advertising / supply-side platformservicedocument, image
*.adnxs.com7No catalog matchthird-partyxhr, document, image
*.adform.net7No catalog matchthird-partyimage, document
*.outbrain.com6Outbrain: advertising / recommendationsserviceimage, document
id5-sync.com6No catalog matchthird-partyfetch, xhr, image
*.dotomi.com6No catalog matchthird-partyimage, document
*.criteo.com5Criteo: advertisingservicefetch, document, image
*.*.stackadapt.com5StackAdapt: advertising / demand-side platformserviceimage, document

+94 more in the evidence explorer below.

Raw evidence

Open the interactive evidence explorer

The findings above are built from the stored report. Load the request rows, domains, cookies, storage keys, browser signals, visit phases, charts and CSV export when you want to check them; the versioned report JSON is always available below without this interface.

This versioned report is currently retained in the public corpus. Follow the currently retained site history, repeat the same public route when it is available, or request a transparent evidence correction.

Report ID
20260817-2134674e3ea29e8ebcf1d4735a978d54
Site
www.theguardian.com
Latest visit
Schema
v1 schema · facts legacy-derived · descriptive report
Verify recorded provenance

Baseline visit

Started
Run quality
cut short: the in-page fingerprint observer could not read every frame, so the fingerprinting evidence is incomplete; derived from status and warnings
Scanner
playwright-chromium
Browser
151.0.7922.34
Redaction
not recorded by this schema
Provenance
Exact build and instrument digests were not recorded by this legacy schema.

Variant visit

Started
Run quality
complete; derived from status and warnings
Scanner
playwright-chromium
Browser
151.0.7922.34
Redaction
not recorded by this schema
Provenance
Exact build and instrument digests were not recorded by this legacy schema.

Recorded provenance is self-reported measurement metadata, not a cryptographic attestation. The public versioned report JSON contains the retained public evidence; see the methodology for interpretation and retention limits.

This report covers what the scanner measures, not everything a site can do. 17 browser surfaces are not instrumented at all (Every page except the one that was scanned; Anything that only loads after scrolling or interaction; Why a request happened, as a causal chain; and 14 others), 3 capabilities are declined by policy, and 3 are outside what any single visit can see. Their absence from this report is not evidence that they did not occur. Read the published coverage boundary.

Detector accuracy is unmeasured. No calibration study currently publishes a precision or recall for the detectors on this page, so a detector match here is a recorded observation, not a calibrated classification. How detector accuracy is measured.

Severity percentiles come from this report's exact schema, methodology, tracker-catalog, ServiceRole-taxonomy, metric-contract, producer, and Global Privacy Control cohort. Each percentile card's measured sites are among 98 sites with a successful load across all cohorts. Other methodologies and post-choice consent visits are excluded from each card's denominator, while failed or block-page attempts are outside that coverage. Visits with capped or incomplete request evidence are left out of each mark. They tend to be the heaviest pages, so a mark can sit lower than the cohort's true mark.

Approved use boundary: This report is investigative evidence that requires independent corroboration. It is not a standalone legal determination and not the sole exhibit in a legal proceeding. Recorded in this project's release manifest on .